An NGSS Science Assessment
from InnerOrbit for

How Do Salmon Survive Salty Seas?

NGSS Phenomena: A salmon jumping out of a flowing river and hitting a bear in the face.
A salmon runs into trouble trying to swim upstream.

Salmon are a type of fish that can live in both freshwater and saltwater. They are born in freshwater and migrate to the ocean to live out most of their life. Freshwater and saltwater have very different properties, making it crucial for salmon to have mechanisms to balance the concentration of both salt and water in their bodies to survive in these environments.

Osmoregulation is the process salmon use to control the water and salt concentration in their bodies. This adaptation makes it possible for them to survive and reproduce in both saltwater and freshwater environments.

Figures 1 and 2 shown how fish like salmon use osmoregulation to control their salt and water ratios in their bodies.

  • Dilute urine: high water concentration, low salt concentration.
  • Concentrated salty urine: low water concentration, high salt concentration.


Figure 1
Fish in Fresh Water
NGSS Phenomena: A diagram of a freshwater fish showing food and freshwater moving in through the mouth and into the gills. Salt ions and water are let out through the urine and both water and ions are absorbed and released through the skin.
The movement of water and ions in freshwater fish.
NOAA


Figure 2
Fish in Salt Water
NGSS Phenomena: A diagram of a saltwater fish showing seawater flowing in and salty urine flowing out through the urine. The gills are able to transport both salt ions and water into the water, and the skin is able to transport both ions and water in and out.
The movement of water and ions in saltwater fish.
Kare Kare, Wikipedia.org

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Osmoseragulation_Carangoides_bartholomaei_bw_en.png



Your classmates decide to experiment to find out what would happen to salmon if they couldn't osmoregulate by placing Gummy Bears in different concentrations of salt and water. The results are shown below in Figure 3.

Figure 3
Gummy Bear Osmosis Experiment
NGSS Phenomena:

References:

Biezl. (2016, September 27). File:Osmoseragulation Carangoides bartholomaei bw en.png. Wikimedia Commons.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Osmoseragulation_Carangoides_bartholomaei_bw_en.png
(Used under [CC BY-SA 3.0])

Raver, Duane. (2009, April 15). File:Bachforelle_osmoregulatoin_bw_en2.png. Wikimedia Commons. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bachforelle_osmoregulatoin_bw_en2.png

Muyzer, G. (2019, November 22). The 'gummi bear osmosis experiment' . Twitter. Retrieved December 20, 2022, from https://twitter.com/muyzer/status/1197890884790034433

1. Which of the following shows the correct order of organization?

2. A salmon is a multicellular organism. The fish's bladder, which helps it regulate its salt concentration, is best described as which part of the organism?

3. Tissues and organs in the body are .

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

able to perform all functions of all tissues
randomly assigned functions
specialized for particular functions

4. Salmon are organisms that have systems of such gills and kidneys that contribute to the salmon's survival.

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

organs
single-celled
multicellular
cells

5. feedback is a response that reverses a change to body systems to maintain homeostasis.

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

neutral
stabilize
destabilize
negative
accelerate
positive

6. When Salmon are exposed to very fresh water, they will dilute their urine so that they can retain salt. This can best be described as:

7. Osmoregulation is an example of a feedback loop.

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

positive
negative

8. The external stimulus that's impacting homeostasis is .

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

depth of water
salt content
osmoregulation
temperature

9. If a pollutant in the water were to affect a salmon’s bladder and its ability to osmoregulate it would:

10. Which of the following best illustrates how salmon use feedback to regulate salt levels in their body?

11. How does feedback allow salmon to live in both freshwater and saltwater environments?

12. One of the MOST difficult things about designing experiments to determine what concentration of salt causes salmon to no longer be able to effectively osmoregulate is:

13. Your classmate suggests testing how well salmon osmoregulate in a fish tank. Another classmate suggests experimenting a river or stream.
Which option offers better control over the salmon’s environment?

14. Based on the Figures and data from the experiment, which conclusion describes the role of feedback in maintaining homeostasis in salmon through osmoregulation?

15. A group of scientists wants to study how salmon use feedback to maintain stability in freshwater and saltwater environments. Which experimental setup would best test this?

16. In the student experiment (Figure 2), each gummy bear started at the same size to simulate how a salmon's cells might be affected by salt concentration if it could not osmoregulate.

While this experiment effectively demonstrates the concept, what is the biggest limitation of using gummy bears to model osmoregulation?

17. Which experiment would produce results that could be generalized beyond the study to help understand feedback mechanisms in salmon?

18. Why might someone experiment on gummy bears to understand osmoregulation rather than live salmon? How could the gummy bear experiment explain how salmon survive different salt concentrations? What are the limitations of using gummy bears?

In your response be sure to discuss:
• How osmoregulation operates through feedback mechanisms
• The conditions of the experiment
• The type of data that could and could not be collected
• How well the experiment represents both internal and external conditions of this system.

19.
Salmon osmoregulate by removing excess salt through salt concentration in their urine (bottom image) or retaining salt by diluting their urine (top image). One of your classmates suggests an experimental design to test osmoregulation in salmon:

"To test how much salt salmon can maintain homeostasis in, we can place a salmon into a tank and slowly add 5 grams of salt each minute to see how the fish responds. When they start struggling to breathe, we can dump them into a large freshwater tank to make sure they're ok. The minute before the fish struggles to breathe, will be considered the amount of salt the fish can survive in."

Refine the experimental design and make suggestions for what they could do to improve the accuracy and reliability of their conclusion along with addressing the ethical concerns of the design.

20. Tissues and organs in the body are .

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

randomly assigned functions
specialized for particular functions
able to perform all functions of all tissues

21. Osmoregulation BEST helps the individual salmon to:

22. In Figure 2, the fish is responding to by using which causes excess salt to be removed.

Drag the answers below into the grey placeholders above

high salt concentration
low salt concentrations
behavior
negative Feedback
polluted water
positive feedback

23. One of your classmates recommends that the best way to test how well salmon osmoregulate is in a large fish tank. Another classmate suggests that the experiments be done in a river or stream.

Which answer best explains the option to have better measurements of the salmon's internal salt concentration?

24. What evidence would be necessary to answer the following question with an experiment:

How well do salmon regulate the amount of salt water in their body?

25. What concerns do you have about the data you'll collect or methods you'll use to collect that data?

26. Osmoregulation is a process that:

27. Your classmate recommends that the best way to test how well salmon osmoregulate is in a large fish tank. A different classmate suggests that the experiments be done in a river or stream.



Which answer best explains the option to have better control over the external environment of the salmon?

28. Which part of the process of osmoregulation in salmon does the gummy bear show very well?

29. In the space below, describe in detail the experimental procedure you would recommend going through to measure salmon's ability to regulate their internal salt content.

Get Started with InnerOrbit

  • Browse All Our Question Clusters

  • Create Your Own Assessments

  • Analyze Student Performance in 3 Dimensions

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This free response question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This free response question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

This matching question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This free response question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • HS-LS1-3

This free response question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • HS-LS1-3

This multiple choice question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

This free response question aligns to the following standards

  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

  • LS1.A: Structure and Function

  • Stability and Change

  • HS-LS1-3

Get Started with 3D NGSS Assessments

How InnerOrbit Works

Select Questions

Choose from pools of rigorous NGSS aligned question clusters

Build Assessments

Copy, remix, and create your own science assessments

Assign to Classes

Students take do-nows, exit slips, and formative or summative assessments

Refocus Lessons

Give feedback, track growth, and use intuitive reports to identify gaps

Create Rigorous Science Assessments

From Phenomena-Based Questions Tagged Individually with Specific NGSS Standards

Choose from Multiple Choice, Drawing, Matching, Fill in the Blank, and Free Response Questions

  • What is the Effect of These Aerosols?

    6 Questions
    Published
    • MS-ESS2-6

  • Why Does This Drop so Slowly?

    16 Questions
    Published
    • MS-PS2-5

  • What Makes Glaciers Change Over Time?

    21 Questions
    Published
    • MS-ESS2-1

  • What Changes are Occurring at the Padma River?

    13 Questions
    Published
    • HS-ESS2-5

  • What is Happening to the California Condor Population?

    14 Questions
    Published
    • MS-LS2-1

  • Which Trash Cleaning Solution is Better?

    13 Questions
    Published
    • MS-LS2-5

  • How do Mushrooms Get Their Energy?

    24 Questions
    Published
    • HS-LS1-7

  • Browse
    1000+
    Questions

Intuitive Reports to Easily View Progress

Track student growth and gaps in three dimensions

    Easily Build and Assign
    Your First NGSS Assessments